quote:So then it becomes apparent that you don't REALLY have to have a priest. It is simply preferable in order to better ensure that the right tone and meaning is being applied to the baptism ceremony.
Anyone can Baptize at any time in cases of emergency
In the same way, it is best to celebrate Eucharist with a priest, in a church, amongst other worshippers in order to ensure that you are cognizant, reverent and prepared for the gift of communion. But the only absolute requirement is the faith and belief of the receiver of said communion.
quote:So completely wrong... But I understand that this is a matter of opinion and neither of us will be able to convince the other.
Second, the matter of the Sacrament (i.e. Eucharistic species) must be bread and wine.
quote:I hadn't heard of Donatus before but I think we are in agreement as to the incorrectness of such a belief.
Having the validity dependent upon the disposition of the celebrant is the old heresy of Donatism.