Overall by far the best since 2013. We are 3 deep. I know everybody doesn't like it that Kyler left, but his old man really slung it for the Aggies.

maroongoon95 said:

---

Wiegman, Henderson, and Reed I believe has to be the best QB room in the history of Aggie football. The only other one I could think of is perhaps Jerrod and Tanehill..... perhaps Johnny and Showers? Bucky, Pavlas, Pullig in the 80's? What y'all think!

---

Ok, I'll bite. It was stupid to sacrifice Tanehill for Jerrod, he was a deer in the headlights like Mond. Showers? who was he? Pavlas was a great high school quarterback playing against high school kids but couldn't handle the pressure playing among the big boys. Pulling was slow! BTW-There was no one with as much killer instinct than Bucky!!
There, you have my take.

Easy, not even close.

****ycup & midget have both put in multiple NFL seasons if we're talking pure talent. Of course that combo proved to be pretty toxic for us.

Think a silly topic and question as based on 'what' context? Yes, like the 'potential' of the QB room today, but what have the really done?

Are we talking about 'star rankings' or games won or conference championships or bowl wins or what? This group hasn't done anything yet IMO.

One can go back in time and see QB rooms that maybe we never say 2nd or 3rd string play much, but who knows as some did go to the NFL to play.

The '98 team had Brandon Stewart, Vance Smith, Randy McGown, Chip Ambres (yes, on the roster, but never appeared), Matt Schobel (who I think ended up being a TE, right?). Is this a better squad cuz they won big 12?

Mid-80s with Murray/Stump won a lot of games (watched many...beat Auburn in Cotton Bowl).

2005 and maybe 2004 had Reggie McNeal, McCoy an McGee (McNeal and McGee did win some big games).

2007 had Johnson, McGee and Tannehill (but don't think he may have been a full QB switch yet).

Anyways, it's about context and perspective, but while the group today seems like it has potential, let's win something of significance to help define them.

ChrisHansen said:

---

I know it's the offseason. But comments like this at anytime are just dumb imo. Who really cares? Only one can play except for an injury, and if the O line lets a qb get hurt again we won't be winning much anyway.

---

Why the pushback?

2002 - Farris, Long, McNeal

Bucky, Pavlas, Pullig in the 80's?

Anybody want to tell him?

Potential…. yes, thanks to Jimbo and Petrino.

We said the same thing when we had Haynes, Max and freshman Weigman. And I think last year too with Weigman and Max and Henderson

Love him, but honestly Weigman hasn't done anything of note yet. Now when you're talking about a program that has had a Heisman winner and multiple pros, this topic is a huge stretch

ChrisHansen said:

---

I know it's the offseason. But comments like this at anytime are just dumb imo. Who really cares? Only one can play except for an injury, and if the O line lets a qb get hurt again we won't be winning much anyway.

---

Ummm....I'm pretty sure that's why position depth matters.

Why do people come onto a football forum to complain about football talk?

If the goal is to delusionally raise expectations then, yes, this is our best QB room EVUH!!!!!

ChrisHansen said:

---

I know it's the offseason. But comments like this at anytime are just dumb imo. Who really cares?

---

I do. We've used backups as starters for the last eleventy zillion seasons and all three of these guys are really, really talented. It's important.

Reno Hightower said:

---

What is the career win/loss record of that group? How many bowl games have they won? Any post-season honors for any of them?

They have a decent amount of POTENTIAL upside, but have proven nothing to this point.

---

Unfortunately that's the basis of A&M football.. hopes / expectations and potential…. Not reality

As much as we all probably hate to admit it, it was probably the QB room that included Kyle Allen, Kyler Murray, and whoever else (that's probably more hindsight and what they've done after they left). I haven't bothered to research it, but other than Sumlin screwed that up, now that time has passed does anyone factually know what happened that led to them both leaving the program within days of each other?

Actual in the moment I would think some combination of Farris and McNeal or Tannehill and Johnson combined may have had very near the tops stats compared to other QB rooms.

I can't believe no one has mentioned Pullig yet!

(I kid, I kid)

Better question is which QB room was most mismsnaged? Should be an easy answer.

Whatever your opinion of the OP's post is, at least it wasn't one of wallowing in the past as so many others do.