He was a stupid hire in the first place. I have wanted to fire him after every season he has been the head coach. Maybe now we will move on.
McCarthy needs to go
5,549 Views |
69 Replies |
Last: 4 mo ago by MountainAg99
Orlando Ayala Cant Read
Joined:
May 17, 2004
Posts:
68,053
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Infection_Ag11 said:Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:
Jerry will make a bunch of emotional decisions after this, that being one of them. Objectively firing a coach that won 37 games in 3 years is really stupid. The chances that you hire someone better are very, very, very low.
It's not an emotional decision at all. How can anyone say "I need to see more from McCarthy and Quinn".
NFL playoffs are about getting in over and over until you get lucky
If they retain him you'll be posting this again next year.
Sweet baby Jesus, please take Jerrah.
Yes he will be.Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:
Jerry will make a bunch of emotional decisions after this, that being one of them. Objectively firing a coach that won 37 games in 3 years is really stupid. The chances that you hire someone better are very, very, very low.
It's not an emotional decision at all. How can anyone say "I need to see more from McCarthy and Quinn".
NFL playoffs are about getting in over and over until you get lucky
If they retain him you'll be posting this again next year.
McCarthy is a regular season merchant. Pretty fitting that his former team is doing this to him.
Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:Orlando Ayala Cant Read said:Infection_Ag11 said:
Jerry will make a bunch of emotional decisions after this, that being one of them. Objectively firing a coach that won 37 games in 3 years is really stupid. The chances that you hire someone better are very, very, very low.
It's not an emotional decision at all. How can anyone say "I need to see more from McCarthy and Quinn".
NFL playoffs are about getting in over and over until you get lucky
If they retain him you'll be posting this again next year.
Yeah, that's the point
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
Don't know if I feel like it's a McCarthy issue. Key players on this team just choke when it counts.
Agree or disagree on the status of McCarthy, I think we can all agree Jerry Jones is the number one issue. Still stand by my McCarthy take, however.
Honest question here - do you all really think Belichick would get along with Jerry Jones? I just can't see a relationship there, or more contentious than anything.
Bellicheat is 71 and looks beaten down. He hasn't won anything since Brady. Why take that chance?
TyHolden said:
Bellicheat is 71 and looks beaten down. He hasn't won anything since Brady. Why take that chance?
Jerry being Jerry thinks he has the team talent to win a superbowl and just needs the right leader
The one constant is Jerry Jones. It's his culture, from top-to-bottom. And, it's a culture where winning is secondary to dollars. Firing McCarthy does nothing to cut out the rotten core of the franchise.
There is no way anyone can watch that game, that game plan, a team clearly not ready to play a playoff game, players mentally checked out, and NOT blame it on coaching. Sorry, this was 100% on the coaches. McCarthy, Quinn, the list goes on…
weak game plan from the start.
If you know you have problems running the ball and stopping the run why not go uptempo and put up points . They let Green Bay dictate flow of game then got behind and put to much pressure on Dak.
lots of issues, but the gameplan was putrid , its like they changed everything they had been doing for this game.
If your going with Dak, let DQ and MM go, you cant trust them.
If you know you have problems running the ball and stopping the run why not go uptempo and put up points . They let Green Bay dictate flow of game then got behind and put to much pressure on Dak.
lots of issues, but the gameplan was putrid , its like they changed everything they had been doing for this game.
If your going with Dak, let DQ and MM go, you cant trust them.
mncag said:
weak game plan from the start.
If you know you have problems running the ball and stopping the run why not go uptempo and put up points . They let Green Bay dictate flow of game then got behind and put to much pressure on Dak.
lots of issues, but the gameplan was putrid , its like they changed everything they had been doing for this game.
If your going with Dak, let DQ and MM go, you cant trust them.
MM had random moments this year where he reverted to the Kellen Moore/Jason Garrett habit of predictably running on first down and running on 2nd and 10 after an incompletion. It didn't happen a lot but it definitely happened today.
This offense was at its best throwing in first down. Dak on first down had a stupid good QBR this year.
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
The Cowboys Achilles Heel is the run defense. Quinn is overrated, and he designed the defense to be a pass rush team first. Good teams neutralize the Cowboys defense by controlling the line of scrimmage and using mobile qbs to complete throws down field.
You do not promote a DC to head coach after today's performance. The Cowboys have to bring in a DC that can force 3rd and longs and not give up 5+ yards a carry.
You do not promote a DC to head coach after today's performance. The Cowboys have to bring in a DC that can force 3rd and longs and not give up 5+ yards a carry.
"You can't grade the success of a CEO by how likeable he is."
This roster with Belichick is what I think Jerry will pursue…
We can debate it as right or wrong all we want, but this is what I think the future holds…
We can debate it as right or wrong all we want, but this is what I think the future holds…
I think if there is a chance to get someone like Vrabel or Harbaugh, then you definitely make the call.
Beyond that, it would be stupid to fire MC for another past prime coach like Belicheck or Carrol.
Wouldn't mind looking at an up and coming coordinator.
Beyond that, it would be stupid to fire MC for another past prime coach like Belicheck or Carrol.
Wouldn't mind looking at an up and coming coordinator.
Vince Young was 31-19 as a starter.
McCarthy can't keep his job just because he piles up regular season wins.
Name one signature win he had this season.
At SF - fail
At Buffalo - fail
At Miami - fail
At Philly - fail
DET at home - miraculous escape
Philly at home - doesn't count
Sure, he can bludgeon haples teams with journeyman QB's. So what.
McCarthy can't keep his job just because he piles up regular season wins.
Name one signature win he had this season.
At SF - fail
At Buffalo - fail
At Miami - fail
At Philly - fail
DET at home - miraculous escape
Philly at home - doesn't count
Sure, he can bludgeon haples teams with journeyman QB's. So what.
94chem,
That, sir, was the greatest post in the history of TexAgs. I salute you. -- Dough
That, sir, was the greatest post in the history of TexAgs. I salute you. -- Dough
Orlando Ayala Cant Read
Joined:
May 17, 2004
Posts:
68,053
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ozamataz Buckshank 01 said:
The Cowboys Achilles Heel is the run defense. Quinn is overrated, and he designed the defense to be a pass rush team first. Good teams neutralize the Cowboys defense by controlling the line of scrimmage and using mobile qbs to complete throws down field.
You do not promote a DC to head coach after today's performance. The Cowboys have to bring in a DC that can force 3rd and longs and not give up 5+ yards a carry.
I posted it yesterday, and a few weeks ago as well. If the Cowboys didn't have Micah Parsons how good would their D be?
I'd say they'd be very very mediocre possibly even leaning bad.
It's time to move on from McCarthy and Quinn. I don't know who they should hire as that's not my job to know that.
Many would argue winning one Super Bowl with 13 years of prime Aaron Rodgers is underachieving.Project Gemini said:
He won a Super Bowl. It is a gross misstatement of fact to say as a coach he cannot win in the playoffs.
94chem said:
Vince Young was 31-19 as a starter.
McCarthy can't keep his job just because he piles up regular season wins.
Name one signature win he had this season.
At SF - fail
At Buffalo - fail
At Miami - fail
At Philly - fail
DET at home - miraculous escape
Philly at home - doesn't count
Sure, he can bludgeon haples teams with journeyman QB's. So what.
only in your make believe world does the Det and philly games not count
Perhaps, but the point still stands that the original post is absolutely a false statement. He has won in the playoffs plenty of times, its just that none of them have been with the Cowboys. Which is not unique to Mike McCarthy for the last few decades.
Only in your make-believe world does reading partial posts count. Or perhaps you believe DET was a signature win.MookieBlaylock said:94chem said:
Vince Young was 31-19 as a starter.
McCarthy can't keep his job just because he piles up regular season wins.
Name one signature win he had this season.
At SF - fail
At Buffalo - fail
At Miami - fail
At Philly - fail
DET at home - miraculous escape
Philly at home - doesn't count
Sure, he can bludgeon haples teams with journeyman QB's. So what.
only in your make believe world does the Det and philly games not count
94chem,
That, sir, was the greatest post in the history of TexAgs. I salute you. -- Dough
That, sir, was the greatest post in the history of TexAgs. I salute you. -- Dough
It doesn't matter who the coach is, Jerry isn't serious about winning. He intentionally stands in the way of it and refuses to change how he does things.
As long as he's in control and there isn't a GM in place who knows what they're doing, the cowboys will continue to be what they are……..an overhyped team that doesn't deserve the attention it generates.
As long as he's in control and there isn't a GM in place who knows what they're doing, the cowboys will continue to be what they are……..an overhyped team that doesn't deserve the attention it generates.
Are the Cowboys going to join the list of teams that want to interview Bobby Slowik? Some websites have mentioned him as a potential replacement for McCarthy.
This is the first year in a while they have choked. The last two years weren't chokes. They just didn't have the best team. Period. Just like if they would have gone to the NFC championship this year. Losing to the 9ers in SF would not have been a choke. It would have been expected.ABATTBQ11 said:
It's not McCarthy. It's the cowboys. No other team chokes as hard in the playoffs. They will not get near another Superbowl until Jerry is dead or sells.
Yes beating Detroit counts and is a signature win whatever the hell that means
I still say McCarthy is not to be trusted in the playoffs. that was one of the biggest choke jobs I've seen and being a Cowboy fan since the '70s
Beating Philly and Detroit were both good wins. When you say otherwise, you look silly.
Losing to Packers would have been a disappointing game. Being completely unprepared on offense and defense was embarrassing. Not making proper adjustments during the game on either side of ball was inept.
Losing to Packers would have been a disappointing game. Being completely unprepared on offense and defense was embarrassing. Not making proper adjustments during the game on either side of ball was inept.
Dak Prescott has a 2-5 record in the postseason.
— NFL on CBS 🏈 (@NFLonCBS) January 15, 2024
No QB has a lower win pct in NFL history, among those with 5+ starts pic.twitter.com/k02Au8gYTV
Source: Cowboys defensive coordinator Dan Quinn will interview for the Panthers and Titans jobs on Wednesday, the Commanders job on Thursday, and the Chargers job on Friday. Those will all be over Zoom.
— Albert Breer (@AlbertBreer) January 15, 2024
Yet he deserves Mahomes pay. Haha…I would trade him off.
baffling game plan and preparation yesterday. negligent.
FireAg said:
This roster with Belichick is what I think Jerry will pursue…
We can debate it as right or wrong all we want, but this is what I think the future holds…
Aligned with you FireAg. I think Jerry will let the games play out today and then make a decision no later than Wednesday.
Featured Stories
See All
2025 Dickinson offensive lineman Tyler Thomas commits to Texas A&M
by Ryan Brauninger
Elko offers optimism for A&M fans at SEC Spring Meetings in Destin
by Olin Buchanan
8:59
18h ago
2.3k
In-Home Visit: Tyler Thomas pushes A&M's 2025 class to 13 in number
by TexAgs Recruiting
3:29
18h ago
2.8k
Dickinson OL Tyler Thomas says culture won out for Elko and A&M
by Ryan Brauninger
36:25
1d ago
10k
The Loochador Podcast: Reacting to Texas A&M's regional draw
by Billy Liucci